January 02, 2009

Origins of Cholera and Molecular Clock recalibration

A casual 100-fold recalibration of the molecular clock should serve as a warning not to take molecular dating too seriously, or at least to make sure to check the premises on which it is based.

PLoS ONE doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0004053

A Recalibrated Molecular Clock and Independent Origins for the Cholera Pandemic Clones

Lu Feng et al.

Cholera, caused by Vibrio cholerae, erupted globally from South Asia in 7 pandemics, but there were also local outbreaks between the 6th (1899–1923) and 7th (1961–present) pandemics. All the above are serotype O1, whereas environmental or invertebrate isolates are antigenically diverse. The pre 7th pandemic isolates mentioned above, and other minor pathogenic clones, are related to the 7th pandemic clone, while the 6th pandemic clone is in the same lineage but more distantly related, and non-pathogenic isolates show no clonal structure. To understand the origins and relationships of the pandemic clones, we sequenced the genomes of a 1937 prepandemic strain and a 6th pandemic isolate, and compared them with the published 7th pandemic genome. We distinguished mutational and recombinational events, and allocated these and other events, to specific branches in the evolutionary tree. There were more mutational than recombinational events, but more genes, and 44 times more base pairs, changed by recombination. We used the mutational single-nucleotide polymorphisms and known isolation dates of the prepandemic and 7th pandemic isolates to estimate the mutation rate, and found it to be 100 fold higher than usually assumed We then used this to estimate the divergence date of the 6th and 7th pandemic clones to be about 1880. While there is a large margin of error, this is far more realistic than the 10,000–50,000 years ago estimated using the usual assumptions. We conclude that the 2 pandemic clones gained pandemic potential independently, and overall there were 29 insertions or deletions of one or more genes. There were also substantial changes in the major integron, attributed to gain of individual cassettes including copying from within, or loss of blocks of cassettes. The approaches used open up new avenues for analysing the origin and history of other important pathogens.

Link

1 comment:

Antigonos said...

As i have said many times in this blog in the past, Genetics is a very, very, very, young science and its tools, methodologies and assumptions are very fragile.
It will take a lot of decades yet for Genetics to create 100% solid methodologies in order to persuade for its findings as a science.