June 29, 2006

Reproductive success of left-handers

Evolution and Human Behavior (Article in Press)

Handedness and reproductive success in two large cohorts of French adults

Charlotte Faurie et al.


Left- and right-handers in humans coexist at least since the Paleolithic, and this variation in hand preference has a heritable basis. Because there is extensive evidence of an association between left-handedness and several fitness costs, the persistence of the polymorphism requires an explanation. It is not known whether the frequency of left-handedness in Western societies is stable or not. If the polymorphism is at equilibrium and maintained by frequency dependence, it implies that the fitness of left-handers equals that of right-handers. On the contrary, if left- and right-handers have a different fitness, the polymorphism will evolve. Using two large cohorts of French adults (men and women), we investigated the relations between handedness and several estimators of the reproductive value: marital status, number of sexual partners (of the opposite sex), number of children, and number of grandchildren. Left-handers seem to have disadvantages for some life-history traits, such as marital status (for women) and number of children. For other traits, we observed sex-dependent interactions with socioeconomic status: for high-income categories, left-handed women report less sex partners and left-handed men have more grandchildren. These kinds of interactions are to be expected under the hypothesis that the polymorphism of handedness is stable.


1 comment:

  1. http://www.masshist.org/photographs/nativeamericans/img-viewer.php?item_id=493&img_step=1&tpc=&pid=&mode=large&tpc=&pid=#page1

    I notice the curious detail, that all five of the Indian warriors posing with their guns in this antique photograph seem to be left-handed (unless the negative got reversed, anyway).

    As a left-hander myself (who sometimes practices marksmanship), I know that even the men holding the rifles on their left side, are also left-handed (apparently).

    I wonder what percentage of Native Americans were left-handed, prior to the Columbus and later invasions.

    Although part Cherokee (matrilineally) on Mother's side of the family, I seem to have inherited my left-handedness from my father (R1b1a2 European ancestry).

    I wonder if left-handedness was more common among paleolithic types (Cro-Magnon, specifically).


Stay on topic. Be polite. Use facts and arguments. Be Brief. Do not post back to back comments in the same thread, unless you absolutely have to. Don't quote excessively. Google before you ask.